Outreach and messaging

LinkedIn Messages That Get Candidates to Reply

How agency recruiters write LinkedIn connection notes, InMails and direct messages that candidates answer, plus how to follow up without pestering.

Candidates reply to LinkedIn messages that are short, specific to them and easy to answer. Say why you picked them, give one concrete reason the role is worth a look, and ask for something small, like a 15-minute call. Use a connection note to open the door, a direct message once you're connected and InMail when you can't connect, then follow up on a different channel.

Should you send a connection note, an InMail or a direct message?

  • Connection request with a note. A good first step for people in your niche you'll want to know for years. LinkedIn caps the length of the note, and a short note reads as less of a pitch anyway. Give a reason to connect rather than pitching the role.
  • Direct message. Once you're connected, your message lands in the same inbox as messages from their colleagues. This is where the role details go.
  • InMail. Reaches people you aren't connected to, which makes it useful for senior or hard-to-reach candidates. Recipients know it's a recruiting message, so the first line has to earn the second.
  • Other platforms. In some trades and creative fields, candidates are more active elsewhere. Use the platform where the candidate actually talks about their work, and follow the same rules.

What should the first message say?

  1. Why them. One specific detail: their current scope, a project or a move they made. "I saw you built the FP&A team at a growing manufacturer" beats "Your background is impressive."
  2. Why this role. One thing that would matter to someone in their seat: bigger scope, ownership, a shorter commute or a path to the next title.
  3. A small ask. "Open to a 15-minute call this week?" Not "Send me your resume."
  4. An easy out. "If the timing's wrong, no problem. I'd still like to stay in touch."

Keep it short enough to read on a phone without scrolling. If you can't name the client yet, describe the company specifically without identifying it: industry, size, location and stage.

How personal does it need to be?

Personal enough that it couldn't go to the next person on your list unchanged. You don't need a paragraph of research. One accurate detail and a reason that fits their career do more than flattery. Write a strong base message for the search, then change the first line and the reason for each person.

An AI assistant can speed this up. Paste the role summary and the highlights of a candidate's public profile, and ask for three short opening lines in your voice. Pick one, edit it and check every detail before you send.

How do you follow up without being a pest?

Most candidates don't answer the first message, often because it arrived on a busy day. Wait a few days, then add something new: a detail about the team, the compensation range or why the role is open. After two LinkedIn touches, switch to email or phone if you have them. Our guide to choosing between email, calls and texts covers when each channel works best.

What should you avoid?

  • Pasting the job description into the message.
  • "Are you open to new opportunities?" with nothing else. It's easy to ignore.
  • Fake familiarity or exaggerated flattery.
  • Messaging people who work at your clients. Agree on off-limits companies with each client before you source.
  • Pressing after a clear no. Thank them, note it and move on.

How do you know which messages work?

Track them. identifyd lets you log each LinkedIn touch, track your connection status with each person and record which message version they received, so you can compare reply rates and drop the openers that don't work.

Frequently asked questions

How long should a LinkedIn message to a candidate be?

Short enough to read on a phone without scrolling: a few sentences covering why them, why the role and a small ask.

Should I mention the salary in my first message?

If the client allows it and the range is strong, yes. A real number is one of the most useful details you can give a passive candidate.

Is InMail worth it for recruiters?

For people you can't connect with, yes, especially senior candidates. Make the first line specific, because recipients know an InMail is a recruiting message.

How many times should I message a candidate on LinkedIn?

Two LinkedIn touches is usually enough. After that, switch channels or set a check-in for a few months out.